Can You Change Your Dog’s Pet Insurance After You Enroll?
Yes, you can change dog insurance coverage after you enroll, but the rules run in one direction. At Healthy Paws, Embrace, and Lemonade, lowering your coverage is simple. Raising it is limited, delayed, or treated like buying a new policy.
This page reads the published terms of those three insurers as they stood on October 28, 2026. It is researched from their own FAQ pages, not from hands-on testing, and it has no prices, because coverage and prices vary by state, age, breed, and plan. For how the companies compare overall, see our guide to the best pet insurance companies.
What each insurer lets you change
Each cell comes from the insurer’s own FAQ. Your state’s policy can differ, so check the sample policy before you rely on it.
| Insurer | Lowering coverage | Raising coverage | The catch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Healthy Paws | Raise the deductible or lower the reimbursement level at any time | Lower the deductible or raise the reimbursement level only if you have submitted no claims | The annual limit chosen at enrollment can never be increased, and a limit that has been lowered stays lowered |
| Embrace | Lower the annual maximum or reimbursement percentage, or raise the deductible, at any time | Allowed at any time, but the policy is re-underwritten like a new one | New waiting periods apply, and anything that started before the upgrade date counts as pre-existing |
| Lemonade | Raise the deductible or lower co-insurance in the app at any time | Within 14 days of purchase; after that, only at renewal | Changes need underwriting approval and can be affected by claims you have filed |
Healthy Paws: the limit you pick is the ceiling
Healthy Paws lets you choose an annual reimbursement limit of $5,000, $7,000, or unlimited at enrollment, along with your deductible and reimbursement percentage. Those are plan options, not quotes, and they can vary by state.
If you have not submitted any claims, you can lower the deductible or raise the reimbursement level, which raises the monthly premium. After you have submitted a claim, you can only raise the deductible or lower the reimbursement level. The annual limit has its own rule: you can switch from unlimited to a set limit, or lower a set limit, once per policy term and only before filing a claim that term. Once decreased, it cannot be raised again, and the limit you chose at enrollment is the highest that policy can ever have. Each pet’s policy can carry a different limit.
Embrace: an upgrade restarts the clock
Embrace says you can adjust coverage at any time. A downgrade means lowering the annual maximum, lowering the reimbursement percentage, or raising the deductible. An upgrade is also allowed, but Embrace says the policy is re-underwritten, which it compares to getting a brand new policy. New waiting periods apply, and any accident or illness that started before the upgrade date is treated as pre-existing, whether or not a claim was ever submitted for it. Our waiting periods chart shows how long four insurers make you wait before coverage starts, which is why a restart matters. Embrace’s FAQ also says exam fee coverage can be removed to reduce the premium.
Lemonade: a 14-day window to raise coverage
Lemonade lets you increase coverage within 14 days of buying the policy. That means lowering the deductible, raising the coverage limit or co-insurance, or adding add-ons and preventative care packages. After 14 days, increases wait until renewal, 12 months after the purchase date. Lowering coverage by raising the deductible or lowering co-insurance can be done in the app at any time. A preventative care package can be removed mid-term only if no preventative claims have been filed. Lemonade adds that any change is subject to underwriting approval and could be affected by claims you have filed.
What the pattern means when you choose a plan
All three treat a cut in coverage as easy and an increase as something to approve, cap, or restart. Their pages do not say why, but the effect is that the coverage you pick on day one may be the most you can ever have on that policy. That is worth weighing before you enroll if you expect to want a higher limit or a lower deductible later, and worth asking the insurer how, or whether, it can be raised. This is general information, not financial advice.
Plan a change before you make it
A short checklist for any coverage change on a dog policy.
- Check whether you have filed a claim this term
Healthy Paws ties some changes to whether you have submitted claims, and Lemonade says claims can affect approval.
- Decide if it is a downgrade or an upgrade
Raising the deductible or lowering the reimbursement rate or limit is a downgrade. The reverse is an upgrade, and upgrades are where the restrictions sit.
- For an upgrade, ask about waiting periods in writing
Embrace says new waiting periods apply and earlier conditions become pre-existing. The Healthy Paws and Lemonade pages read for this guide did not say, so ask them directly.
- Get the new premium before you confirm
Healthy Paws says a lower deductible or higher reimbursement level raises the monthly premium, so confirm the figure first.
- Note the renewal date
Lemonade holds increases until renewal after the first 14 days, and Healthy Paws resets the annual deductible on the enrollment anniversary.
Questions dog owners ask about changing coverage
Sometimes. Healthy Paws allows a lower deductible or higher reimbursement only if you have submitted no claims, and its annual limit can never be raised. Embrace allows upgrades but re-underwrites the policy with new waiting periods. Lemonade allows increases within 14 days of purchase, then only at renewal.
Yes, at all three. Raising the deductible and lowering the reimbursement level are options at each, and Healthy Paws also lets you move from unlimited to an annual limit once per policy term, before any claim that term.
It can. Healthy Paws limits you to raising the deductible and lowering reimbursement once you have submitted a claim, and Lemonade says changes can be affected by claims you have filed.
At Embrace, yes: an upgrade brings new waiting periods, and anything that began before the upgrade date counts as pre-existing. The Healthy Paws and Lemonade pages read for this guide did not say, so ask before you upgrade.
Policy pages read for this guide
All pages were read on October 28, 2026. Insurers change their terms, so confirm with the sample policy before you change anything. Healthy Paws and Embrace both publish sample policy terms.
- Healthy Paws: frequently asked questions
- Embrace: coverage frequently asked questions
- Lemonade: pet FAQ
This guide sits in our Health and Care section. Coverage and prices vary by state, age, breed, and plan.
This guide has not yet been reviewed by a veterinarian.
